Family “shocked” by shoe pitchman

Via the Bhutan Observer:

Sight-seeing in Switzerland does not leave a vacationer horrified, but Prabhat Choudhary, his wife and daughter were shocked to see a Lord Buddha statue garlanded with a pair of shoes at a footwear shop in Geneva.

“We were strolling on shopping street when my 15-year-old daughter insisted that we got into ‘Anne Fontaine’, a designer footwear shop. There in the shop, we saw a 4-ft statue of Lord Buddha on the shelf displaying shoes and slippers, garlanded with a pair of shoes,” Prabhat, a realtor, recalled.

The family was shocked. Prabhat’s daughter, was furious. Though her parents were a bit frightened, she persuaded them to let her shoot the sight with her videocam. The girl, a student of Patna’s prestigious Notre Dame Academy, accomplished her mission without anyone – the shop staff or the crowd of customers – knowing about it.

Back home, Prabhat has sent a letter to the ministry of external affairs, requesting it to take up the matter with Swiss authorities.

9 Comments »

  1. avatar
    orkneyearl Says:
    June 26th, 2009 at 9:10 am
    comment-top

    I’m not sure how this is a big deal, really. Sure, it’s a little disrespectful, and I’d be surprised to see a statue of Buddha used for this purpose in a more buddhist nation, but in Switzerland I’m more surprised they even thought to use a Buddha statue.

    I think the outrage here may be a little displaced. Perhaps, instead of taking furtive photos and sending them to a government agency to get the statue removed, the person may have been better served by speaking quietly and privately with the manager of the store. A simple explanation of how the use of the statue may be in bad taste (in the same way it would be bad taste to display shoes dangling from a crucifix), and that they could be offending customers (some of whom may decide to take their business elsewhere).

    Really, though. It’s just a statue. I have a Buddha statue in my home that I make hats for, which it “wears” during special occasions (i.e. a red toque during christmas, a pair of rabbit ears at easter, a green top hat on St. Patrick’s day, etc.). I, for one, think Buddha would think it’s a fun idea.

    To each their own, though, I guess.

    comment-bottom
  2. avatar comment-top

    Huh?

    Write a letter to the government over this? Really?

    I guess I am missing the part where this is offensive.

    I went through a mall recently and saw a large fat happy Buddha pointing the way inside. I gasshoed and moved on. Big deal.

    comment-bottom
  3. avatar
    Dave "Above The Law" Says:
    June 29th, 2009 at 7:54 pm
    comment-top

    Seriously, fuck anyone who wants to try and force our governments to modify our freedom of speech to suit their own little world. Fuck the people who threatened violence over cartoons and knighting Pakistani writers, and fuck these Bhutanese rubes for trying to involve Swiss authorities. If you’re too provincial to not travel without getting your balls in a twist, stay home.

    comment-bottom
  4. avatar comment-top

    imagine someone going up to an image of the most sacred thing in your culture and wiping a big green booger across it.
    pointing ones feet at someone or putting your shoes on the Buddha are just as offensive to these people.
    its a cultural difference. the offense is about the feet/shoes being placed upon the Buddha. This is seen as very disrespectful in Bhutan.

    comment-bottom
  5. avatar comment-top

    I understand that this statue is “just” a statue, and that the garland of shoes is “just” a garland of shoes. Still for some of us, this composition is symbolically appalling, and others’ ignorance of the hugely offensive symbolism is, to put it politely, disappointing. There is a good explanation over at Enlightenment Ward.

    comment-bottom
  6. avatar comment-top

    Symbols are powerful things. Why is it illegal to burn the American Flag in the U.S? Isn’t it only a piece of cloth.

    comment-bottom
  7. avatar comment-top

    I received this email from Anne Fontaine regarding the Buddha with shoe garland. Apparently the store is VIA ROMA and not Anne Fontaine. Read below:
    Dear Tony,

    We found this shocking article in the Indian times.

    Please be advised that this is not an image of the Anne Fontaine store in Geneva. Anne Fontaine is a French luxury retailer specializing in white blouses and does not sell footwear of any kind. This is an image of our neighbouring store VIA ROMA. Anne Fontaine respects all religions and would never outwardly disrespect or mock the Buddhist faith.

    I have attached a picture of our Anne Fontaine shop in Geneva. As you can see, it is totally different from what is shown in the article.

    Best regards,

    Sales & Marketing Assistant
    aNNE FONTaINE INC
    110 Greene Street
    Suite 301
    New York, NY 10012

    comment-bottom
  8. avatar comment-top

    I found a statute of the Buddha in the changing room of my hair salon. An innocent, though insensitive and ignorant, effort at exotic “decor”. I spoke to the owner and it was gone before I left that day. I wish I knew where it went, now that I think about it. Most people, in my experience, do not want to offend anyone. I will have to excise Dave, above, from that generalization, however.

    comment-bottom
  9. avatar comment-top

    I understand the reaction of those people: judging by their name they are Thai nationals and in Thai culture it is a BIG insult to for example point your foot at someone, even worst at a Buddha statue…and it is even worst to use a Buddha statue to present shoes (that are even lower than the foot)

    Really one need to know the Thai and the way they react to understand this reaction…what look to be rather trivial to us is very serious to them.
    Thailand has VERY restrictive laws in place to avoid any Thai Buddhist statue to end up as mere decoration in Europe.

    Last time i was in Thailand i remember a Thai asking about if i knew about some place in Switzerland where they had a Buddha statue displayed in a disco…
    Apparently one friend of this person had told him about this and it was big deal for him…Now it was likely a rather obscure disco and i m French, so really why asking me as if i could change it?!?

    comment-bottom

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment